Martin Scorsese has re-teamed with his latest muse, Leonardo Di Caprio, for “Shutter Island”, the latest Dennis Lehane novel to be adapted for the screen. Expectations for a Scorsese film are always high, and whilst it’s certainly not his best, it may have been someone else’s best.

Set in Massachusetts in 1954, “Shutter Island” tells the story of Edward “Teddy” Daniels (Di Caprio), a U.S Marshal and WWII veteran who is sent to Ashecliffe Hospital, an asylum for the criminally insane, which is located on the titular island. Daniels is there to investigate the disappearance of one of the hospital’s patients with his brand new partner, Chuck Aule (Mark Ruffalo). Upon their arrival by ferry to the island, they are greeted by a tense staff and seemingly suspicious Head Psychiatrist, Dr. Cawley (Ben Kingsley), who often seem to hide and distort the facts. As Daniels investigates the disappearance, he becomes obsessed with finding the truth behind Ashecliffe and Shutter Island, and soon discovers that all is not as it seems.
I’m going to be careful to not give anything away here. Not just because a lot of the enjoyment you’ll get from this film is not knowing how it ends, but also because not knowing exactly how it looks or sounds will play a big part in how much you enjoy this picture also. Despite heavy and possibly undeserved expectations placed on his shoulders, Scorsese seems to really embrace the subject matter here, and can be seen running away with the gorgeous sets, inspiring dream sequences and interesting editing. A lot of what you’ll take away from this film can be credited directly to the director, which of course speaks volumes about his talent and genius. Having said that, the only real let down appears to be the screenplay, which is heavy handed at times, and leaves little room for subtlety. Though the major climaxes and plot turns are well handled, it would appear this is more the work of excellent performances by a solid cast, as opposed to an outstanding script. The actors clearly carry the story.
Di Caprio as Daniels is excellent. But then, he’s a talented actor working with an outstanding director that he’s come to know very well, so perhaps any performance here that wasn’t of an excellent standard would be unacceptable. Ruffalo is engaging, and the Noir edge he gives to his performance does not go unnoticed. The standouts for me are definitely Ben Kingsley, as the often confusing but always intriguing Dr. Crawley, and also Michelle Williams, in her brief role as Daniel’s wife, Delores. She owns her limited screen time. Special mention should also go to Ted Levine, as the Ashecliffe Warden… His single one-on-one scene with Di Caprio’s Daniels is truly excellent.
This is certainly an enjoyable thriller, and will keep you on the edge of your seat for the entire duration of the picture. Is it Scorsese’s best? Well, no. But if this exact film came from another director, perhaps one who is lesser known, you have to wonder if it would be held to the same high standard that we’re holding it in now. Taking that into account, it’s hard to fault this film beyond the clunky adapted screenplay. There’s flashes of vintage Scorsese in there, with some brilliant tense moments and some shots and edits that can only be his, but ultimately this film stands alone as a very good, very enjoyable thriller, with a fantastic score and excellent performances.

© 2009 pop-gospel.com